
Order No. P.951030
IN THE MATTER of the
Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission
Act, Stats. P.E.I. 1991 Chapter 18; and the Petroleum Products Act, R.S.P.E.I. 1988, Cap. P-5.1;
- and -
IN THE MATTER
of an application made by Co-Op Atlantic for an
initial petroleum products license in respect of full-serve motor fuels dispensing in
conjunction with the existing general merchant outlet operated by Central Farmers
Co-operative Association, Limited located at Oak Tree Place, Queen Street, Charlottetown,
Prince Edward Island.
Monday, the 30th day of October, A.D., 1995
BEFORE
Linda Webber, Chairman
James Nicholson, Commissioner
Carl Riggs, Commissioner
Decision and Order
TABLE OF CONTENTS
APPEARANCES AND WITNESSES
DECISION
I. INTRODUCTION
II. REVIEW OF EVIDENCE
III. REASONS FOR DECISION
ORDER
APPEARANCES AND WITNESSES
Participants in the hearing and the parties for whom they appeared were as follows:
FOR APPLICANT, CO-OP ATLANTIC
Counsel: William G. Lea
Witnesses: G. F. (Gerry) Power
Jill Farquharson
Ernest V. Jones
FOR OPPOSING INTERVENERS:
IRVING OIL LIMITED
Counsel: Eugene P. Rossiter
Witness: Gerry Moore
MRS. MARGARET COFFIN AND OTHERS
Witness: Joseph Cairns
THREE CHARLOTTETOWN AREA DEALERS
Wayne Vloet, C/o Avenue Service Station (Shell)
Ronald C. Callaghan, C/o Argyle Service Centre (Ultramar)
Robert Taylor, C/o Imperial Service Station
Witnesses: Wayne Vloet
Ronald C. Callaghan
Robert Taylor
FOR THE COMMISSION:
H. Doris Pursey, Director - Petroleum Division
Harry MacDonald, Assistant to Director - Petroleum Division
RECORDING SECRETARY:
Faye Weeks
Decision
I. INTRODUCTION
A public hearing commenced on July 6, 1995 to deal with an application
by Co-Op Atlantic (signed by Gerry Power, Manager, Petroleum Department) for initial
licensing under the Petroleum Products Act covering full-serve dispensing of motor fuels
in conjunction with the existing general merchant outlet operated by Central Farmers
Co-operative Association, Limited at Oak Tree Mall in Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island.
Notice of this application dated April 11, 1995 appeared in the public press, with
interventions either in support of or in opposition to the granting of this license to be
filed by May 8, 1995.
1. Irving Oil Limited
P. O. Box 366
Charlottetown, P. E. I.
C1A 7K7
2. Mrs. Margaret Coffin
426 Queen Street
Charlottetown, P. E. I.
C1A 4E7
(Petition attached.)
3. Mr. Wayne Vloet
c/o Avenue Service Station (Shell)
201 University Avenue
Charlottetown, P. E. I.
C1A 4L4
4. Mr. Ronald C. Callaghan
C/o Argyle Service Centre
412 University Avenue
Charlottetown, P. E. I.
C1A 4N6
5. Mr. Robert Taylor
c/o Imperial Service Station
122 Euston Street
Charlottetown, P. E. I.
C1A 1W4
As a result of this Notice, several written interventions in opposition to
this application were filed, as follows:
The Commission then fixed the date and time for the commencement of
this hearing, and Notice of Hearing dated June 1, 1995 was published in the
Guardian-Patriot newspapers.
At the commencement of this hearing Counsel for the Applicant, William G.
Lea, indicated that although the application was made by Co-Op Atlantic, it was made by it
on behalf of Central Farmers Co-operative Association, Limited.
A total of three witnesses testified in support of the application of
Co-Op Atlantic. Five witnesses gave evidence in support of the interventions filed. A
complete listing of those appearing on behalf of the above-noted interventions can be
found on page 3 of this Decision.
A total of thirty-seven exhibits were entered in this hearing, which
was reconvened on July 7 and 10, 1995. Closing summations by Counsel were given verbally
at this hearing. At the adjournment of the hearing, the Chairman gave instructions to
Counsel with respect to the filing of further information requested as the hearing
proceeded and also resulting from a specific issue raised by Mr. Rossiter during the
course of the hearing. Counsel was also advised that following the filing of this
additional material, the matter would be taken under advisement by the Commission and the
parties notified once its Decision has been reached.
II. REVIEW OF EVIDENCE
As previously indicated, William G. Lea, acting for the Applicant,
called three witnesses in support of the application. These witnesses were G. F. (Gerry)
Power, Manager - Petroleum Department, and Jill Farquharson, Sales and Operation Manager,
both of Co-Op Atlantic, and Ernest V. Jones, General Manager of Central Farmers
Co-operative Association, Limited. The evidence in chief of these witnesses was contained
in a prefiled document which was entered as Exhibit No. 16 at this hearing.
The evidence given provided the hearing panel with a background of the
Central Farmers' Co-operative Association, the location of the proposed outlet, the number
of members in the organization, and operational and membership criteria. The principal
reason given for the application was so that the Co-op could offer to consumers in its
market area the ability to purchase gasoline, on a co-operative basis, from a conventional
rebate co-op (as distinguished from a direct charge co-op.) Conventional co-ops offer
goods and services to the general public, not just co-op members, with members being
entitled to patronage rebates from sales. The evidence suggested that the gas bar portion
of the operation would be treated separately for patronage rebate purposes. The Applicant
stated that as a member of a co-op a customer gets the benefit of savings through
patronage rebates once the operation reaches profitability, and went on to say that
patronage rebates are the equivalent of dividends distributed in proportion to purchases.
Direct-charge co-ops, on the other hand, offer goods and services to members only, with
potential savings realized at the time of purchase.
The evidence given indicated that the motor fuels outlet would be
located on a parcel of land 120 feet by 60 feet to be leased from the owner of the Oak
Tree Mall (B.L.M. Investments Limited) at the intersection of Queen and Pond Streets. This
land is not directly connected to the lands owned by Central Farmers' Co-operative
Association Limited on which its general merchant outlet is located. The Applicant
provided responses relative to the particulars of this lease, and agreed to provide a copy
of the lease to the Commission on a confidential basis if necessary. The outlet would be
comprised of two underground fuel storage tanks, two blender pumps, a canopy and a kiosk.
Co-Op Atlantic would construct the facility, and it would be operated by Central Farmers'
Co-operative Association Limited, a conventional co-operative with approximately three
thousand active members. In addition to gasoline such automotive products as motor oil,
windshield wiper fluid, wiper blades and fuses would be available. Co-Op Atlantic would
also provide staff training and continuing technical support as required, and supply the
outlet with petroleum products. It is proposed that this outlet would operate from 7 a.m.
to 9 p.m. Mondays to Fridays and 7:30 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on Saturdays.
It was indicated that the two phases of the operation--grocery store
and gas bar--would complement each other, and provide efficiencies such as additional
flexibility in assigning staff and the economic benefits of providing one-stop shopping
for members and other residents of the area. Testimony indicated that this arm of the
operation would provide employment for one full-time and four part-time employees.
Testimony was given that there is only one other service station
directly accessible from Queen Street, being the Irving station on the corner of Euston
and Queen Streets. A traffic count had been conducted based on criteria obtained from the
Department of Transportation and Public Works, the results of which were shown in Schedule
1 of Exhibit l6.
Testimony was also given that the volume sales in the general area
has increased in 1994 over 1993, and also that the population has increased since 1991 by
approximately 5% in several communities in the Applicant's market area, as indicated by
the Charlottetown Information Bureau.
With respect to competition, testimony was given that while the
present services do not indicate an inadequacy in the services presently provided, in the
opinion of the Applicant, the consuming public has a legitimate interest in as wide an
array of choices as a market can provide, and the ability to purchase as a member of this
Co-op is one such choice not presently available.
Demand for the services proposed was supported by a survey of Co-op
shoppers, which survey was conducted over a four-week period in December, 1994 and
January, 1995, and was reproduced as Schedule 4 of Exhibit l6. Most of the 1,034 people
surveyed, whether members or non-members, indicated support for the gas bar proposal. A
conservative figure of l.8 million litres per annum was given as an anticipated volume for
this site--with an expectation that this would increase to approximately 2.25 million over
time. The capital cost of the project was given as $315,000.00, to be financed by Co-op
Atlantic and paid for by rent which would recover depreciation, insurance and maintenance
costs. It was the opinion of the Applicant that the volume to be achieved will be spread
over many outlets over a wide market area, and thus not have a serious detrimental effect
on other central or downtown motor fuels outlets.
The Applicant summarized its case in part by concluding that
"Co-operative purchasing of goods and services is a legitimate consumer strategy. It
offers potential savings to consumers and, equally as important, it offers consumers a say
in how their supplier is operated". It noted that Central Farmers' is a conventional
co-operative with about three thousand active members, and that both members and
non-members supported the addition of a gas bar to the Co-op's service.
Joseph Cairns spoke on behalf of Mrs. Margaret Coffin and others
(letter of intervention and accompanying petition filed as Exhibit No. 8) prior to the
commencement of the Applicant's testimony. Mr. Cairns gave his address as 15 Pond Street,
and noted that this outlet, if established, would be located less than fifty feet from the
side of his residential lot. Mr. Cairns produced Exhibit 17 while giving testimony, which
exhibit indicates the location of some of the residents who signed the petition which
accompanied Mrs. Coffin's letter in relation to the intersection of Pond and Queen
Streets. He expressed concerns relative to traffic congestion and noise pollution, and
advanced the opinion that there were presently too many motor fuels outlets in the market
area. He referred to several accidents which had occurred at this busy intersection over
the years. He also expressed concern about Co-op members not having an opportunity to vote
on this significant project.
Eugene P. Rossiter called only one witness on behalf of the Intervener
Irving Oil Limited, that being Gerry Moore. Several exhibits were entered into the hearing
on behalf of this Intervener, which exhibits formed the basis for much of the direct and
cross-examination.
The witness, Gerry Moore, was very adamant that this application should
not be approved. Mr. Moore raised concerns respecting the creating of a
"non-level" playing field should this application be approved, in that
conventional co-operatives have the ability to rebate to their members some of the profits
earned at the outlet. Mr. Moore indicated in his testimony that if this application were
approved, Irving would close at least one and possibly two nearby service stations rather
than upgrade their existing underground storage.
Mr. Moore also strenuously argued that the market area used by the
Applicant for its analysis was far too extensive to be meaningful. The "market
area" was defined by the Applicant as being equivalent to the geographical area in
which Co-op members lived. Mr. Moore's position was that an analysis for the purposes of
looking at the impact of a petroleum products outlet should involve a considerably smaller
area.
Wayne Vloet, Ronald Callaghan and Robert Taylor took the stand as a
panel, but testified individually respecting their own businesses and concerns in relation
to this application. Each of these three witnesses operates a motor fuels outlet in the
general vicinity of the proposed Oak Tree location. Testimony was given relative to
declining gasoline sales volumes in the core area of Charlottetown. All were firmly of the
opinion that they would be detrimentally affected by the granting of the requested license
and were also firmly of the opinion that an additional outlet in the area is unnecessary
to meet the reasonable needs of the motoring public.
During the hearing Counsel for Irving Oil Limited raised an objection
relating to the jurisdiction of the Commission with regard to licensing under the
Petroleum
Products Act when one is dealing with a co-operative business, and requested an
opportunity to file a written submission by Monday, July 17, 1995. This request was
granted and Counsel for the Applicant was given the opportunity of then filing a response
in this regard by the following Monday, July 24, 1995.
III. REASONS FOR DECISION
The Commission has considered the extensive verbal evidence put before
it in this matter, as well as the thirty-seven exhibits placed in evidence.
The primary focus of this hearing was the "co-operative"
nature of this application. The Applicant's position was that what is unique about this
proposed outlet is that it gives people the opportunity to purchase the "Co-op
way." That was also the focus of opponents to this application--the unfairness of
allowing rebates in a regulated market; the creation of an uneven playing field.
We also note that this is not a case where any argument can be made
that an outlet is needed because the community in question is inadequately served by the
number of outlets presently available to the prospective customer base. In a case like
this, where there is already considerable competition for the customer base and no
distance problem for any customers being resolved by the location of the new outlet, the
Commission must look closely at the application to see whose interests it is really
intended to serve and what the likely impact of granting such a license would be on
existing licensees.
During the course of the hearing, Counsel for the Intervener Irving Oil
Limited raised the issue of conflicting statutes in connection with the Petroleum
Products Act, R.S.P.E.I. 1988, Cap. P-5.1 and the Co-operative Associations Act, R.S.P.E.I. 1988, Cap. C-23 arguing that the
Petroleum Products Act was
paramount and that therefore, the Commission did not have the jurisdiction to grant the
application in question.
The Petroleum Products Act states that prices for petroleum
products for each wholesaler shall be universal across P.E.I. and that the Commission
shall approve all prices; the Co-operative Associations Act states that
co-operative associations may form, and that these associations may distribute rebates to
members out of profits from sales. The Intervener argued that this allows Co-op members
to, effectively, purchase at a price different from the price approved by the Commission
under the Petroleum Products Act.
Irving and other retailers argued that this violates the principle of
an "even playing field" for competition in the industry: How can they expect to
attract customers when the Co-op virtually guarantees them a cheaper price?
The answer posed by the Applicant's Counsel was that co-ops are allowed
in the Province, no matter what effect this may have on the "even playing
field." Mr. Lea pointed out that s.37 of the Co-operative Associations Act
states that:
(1) Notwithstanding any other
Act of this province, the allocation or
payment by a co-operative association of its net savings or any other amount available for
distribution or any part of the savings or other amount to or among its patrons does not
constitute a payment or distribution
(a) of a premium, discount, fund, refund, rebate, interest or dividend;
(b) a failure to charge a fixed or prescribed price for any commodity;
or
(c) a failure to maintain the price for any commodity
but does constitute the gains which are distributed among the members
or patrons in proportion to the use they make of the co-operative services in their
association.
(2) Where members of an association are required by a marketing plan
established under an Act of the Legislature or the Parliament of Canada to sell or deliver
goods or render services to or for a marketing board, for the purpose of distributing the
net savings of the association to the members thereof in accordance with this
Act, the
members shall be deemed to have sold, delivered or rendered those goods or services to the
association. 1976, c.7,s.37.
In response to this the Intervener Irving Oil Limited has argued in a
written brief that the words "Notwithstanding any other Act of this province..."
need to be interpreted as having meaning only in relation to the laws in existence at the
time those words were enacted. The case of Re Mitchell and Department of Labour
(1977), 78 D.L.R. (3d) 631 at p. 637. (Man. Q.B.) is cited in support of this argument.
In addition to this being rather weak authority, the Commission feels
that the circumstances of that case are so unique that they can provide no assistance to
this Intervener. In that case the same subject matter--payment of employee wages--was
being dealt with by two pieces of legislation. On the face of it, there appeared a direct
conflict in the provisions of these two statutes on this same subject. The court
determined that the conflict would be resolved if the words "Notwithstanding the
provisions of any other Act of the Legislature" were read as applicable only to
legislation in effect at the time the legislation was enacted, otherwise they created the
absurdity of later legislation on the same subject being of no force and effect.
This principle was stated in another way by Locke, J. (S.C.C.) in Greenshields
v. The Queen as cited in R. v. Greenwood (1992), 70 C.C.C. (3d) 260
at pp. 265-266 (found at Tab 17 of the Intervener Irving's submission):
"In Greenshields v. The Queen (1958), 17 D.L.R. (2d)
33, [1958] S.C.R. 216, [1959] C.T.C. 77, the Supreme Court of Canada was called upon to
reconcile a statutory conflict. Locke J., although dissenting in the result, expressed the
applicable principle of statutory construction at pp. 42-3 as follows:
In the case of conflict between an earlier and a later statute, a
repeal by implication is never to be favoured and is only effected where the provisions of
the later enactment are so inconsistent with, or repugnant to, those of the earlier that
the two cannot stand together. Unless the two Acts are so plainly repugnant to each other
that effect cannot be given to both at the same time, a repeal cannot be implied. Special
Acts are not repeated by general Acts unless there be some express reference to the
previous legislation or a necessary inconsistency in the two Acts standing together which
prevents the maxim generalia specialibus non derogant being applied (Broom's Legal
Maxims, 10th ed., p. 349: Maxwell...op. cit., p.176)."
The Petroleum Products Act appears to have been enacted to deal
specifically with the licensing, sale and distribution of petroleum products. The
Co-operative
Associations Act was created to allow a special form of business even though such form
might conflict with rules created to regulate other businesses--with s.37 put in to
indicate the firm intention of the legislature to allow co-ops in spite of the unique
position this might put them in from time to time.
Overall, the Commission cannot accept the interpretation proposed by
Irving's Counsel on this point.
Another point raised in this Intervener's brief related to the
provisions of the Co-operative Associations Act and whether or not the application
of the Co-op met all the legal requirements of that Act. While the Commission
agrees with the Applicant that these matters should have been raised by the Intervener
Irving Oil Limited at the hearing, some issues may only have been identified after the
evidence of the Applicant was heard. However, in the circumstances of the decision come to
by the Commission it is not felt necessary to delve any further into this issue.
This does not totally dispose of the arguments made by several of the
Interveners against the unfairness of Co-op sales. While we have found that the rebate
system is not, in law, a violation of the Petroleum Products Act, we still have
questions about the purpose of the Co-operative Associations Act and the validity
of the "Co-op buying" argument in this particular case.
We note that s.2 of the Co-operative Associations Act states:
The purpose of this Act is to provide for the incorporation,
inspection, examination and supervision of associations whose primary purpose is to
provide service to their members and which belong to the people who use their services,
the control of which rests equally with all their members, and the gains from which are
distributed among the members in proportion to the use they make of these services. 1976,
c.7,s.2.
There is an emphasis in that section on the primary purpose of
such an association being service to members and emphasis on ownership by
the people who use the services. While sales to non-members may not be disallowed,
such sales were not the designated purpose of the Act.
Yet the Co-op's evidence was that perhaps 50% of its customers are
non-members. This would put it in the position of seriously competing against other
retailers of gasoline without being totally subject to the same restrictions. While it is
true that sales to non-members would be at the regulated price without a rebate, the
incentive of a possible rebate to get customers who would otherwise buy gas elsewhere
could be enough to keep the outlet going in a market that would otherwise be non-viable.
That is, as Mr. Moore said when testifying for Irving, there will always be some
people who buy gas at a new outlet because it is likely more convenient for them. This
combined with incentive sales to members would likely aid the viability of the outlet.
Is this a problem? Yes, if such is at the expense of other outlets and
as a result the motoring public's interest, convenience and necessity is in the end less
well served.
The Commission accepts the evidence of the Interveners that sales in
the core area of Charlottetown are declining. It also accepts that buying patterns are
different in the core area than the arterial bypass area. The sales records support these
conclusions.
As well, the Commission must agree with the Interveners that the market
area proposed by the Applicant is inappropriate. While for the Co-op's purposes grocery
store members may be their market, all analyses of gasoline sales we have ever seen would
indicate that consumers are unlikely to drive long distances for gasoline product.
The argument made by the Applicant is that the rebate would make their
customers loyal--as well as their general loyalty to co-op buying. As for general loyalty,
while it is a nice sentiment, there was no foundation for it. Of its approximately 6,300
members (Exhibit 34) the Co-op has only approximately 3,000 who are considered active.
That doesn't support the general loyalty argument.
If the Co-op could guarantee a rebate then perhaps there would be an
incentive. However as the Intervener Irving Oil Limited pointed out, the rebate can only
be given after the fiscal year end and out of any profits that were made. So there is no
guarantee.
Given the declining sales in the core areas, the likelihood of a profit
is in question. The Co-op's evidence is that break-even sales are 1.2 million litres
annually. They actually expect to sell 1.8 to 2.25 million litres annually. If two million
litres are sold, this is approximately 14% of the total volume sales for 1994 at the 11
outlets in the core area (Exhibit 27), and 4.3% of total volume sales for the 26 outlets
in the area from the Charlottetown waterfront to the arterial highway (Exhibit 14). We
would expect the Co-op's sales to fall within this range in terms of impact on other
outlets, with the heaviest impact likely to occur on the core area outlets. Such an impact
would, given these numbers, appear significant.
Then we must consider the evidence given to us of the services already
available to motorists in the Charlottetown area and the potential loss of services if
this new gas bar is approved. The history of sales in this area supports the Intervener's
position that further competition will hurt existing operators and may well force some to
close. There are declining sales in this area.
While the Co-op insists that, since its members come from beyond the
central core, business will be taken from a large number of outlets and not the central
core, this contradicts normal gas buying patterns. While it may be true enough to lessen
such an impact, all indications would suggest the predominant impact would be in that core
area.
The service issue also raises the issue of whether or not the approval
of a gas bar is appropriate. In this case we have a proposal for gas pumps to be located
on premises separate and apart from the grocery store we are told it is to be associated
with. The sole purpose of the gas bar is to sell gas. In all previous applications the
Commission was looking at a bundle of services to the motoring public: gas sales plus one
or more of mechanical services to automobiles, car washing, convenience store shopping,
sales of auto supplies. The existing Central Farmers' grocery store business cannot, in
the Commission's opinion, be viewed as synonymous with convenience stores. Convenience
stores, even those that approach a small grocery level, are designed in most cases for the
convenience of the motoring public. They fill a need and filling up with gas while picking
up bread and milk has been accepted as a convenience combination for the motorist.
The operation proposed by the Applicant, however, more resembles a gas
bar on a vacant lot in a downtown area--or, as it really is, a gas bar on the parking lot
of a shopping mall--than a convenience store operation. The Central Farmers' Co-op store
is not there primarily to serve motorists running in for a litre of milk and loaf of
bread. There is not even any parking on the lot reserved for the gasoline sales operation.
The hours of operation proposed are not identical to the hours of operation of the grocery
store with which it is to be associated. As well, very few customers of the Central
Farmers' Co-op would not pass an existing retail gasoline outlet on their way to that
store.
This type of operation brings more clearly into focus the issue of
service to the motoring public and the interests to be balanced here.
The balance of interests here appears to be: on the one side, the
opportunity for a Co-op to enhance its business; and on the other side, the preservation
of a variety of automotive related services in the downtown core area. While the Applicant
categorized that this was "an opportunity to buy co-op", the large amount of
non-co-op sales suggests that a broader view of what is being proposed is appropriate.
This is not to lose sight of other concerns raised at the hearing
related to safety and the appropriateness of a gas bar in a highly residential area. There
were 19 names on the statement opposing this gas bar (Exhibit 8). Mrs. Coffin explained
her reasons fully in a letter--saying there are enough gas stations in Charlottetown; that
although the site in question is commercially zoned, it borders on a residential area; and
the traffic is very bad at that corner. Mr. Cairns appeared at the hearing to explain his
objections, saying although he was a Co-op member he was opposed to it because it was too
close to his house and he was personally aware of several accidents at that corner,
including a fatality. The efforts made by these people to be heard on this issue are
appreciated.
While some effort was made to suggest a "need" for gasoline
sales on Queen Street at this location by doing a traffic survey, the Commission does not
accept the volume of traffic as indicative of need. In the downtown core there are many
other outlets operating in quite close proximity and, while heavily travelled, Queen
Street is not a main arterial for the motoring public.
The survey filed by the Applicant is of some value in its indication of
an interest by shoppers in a Co-op gas bar. One wonders if the location of the gas bar was
ever mentioned to those surveyed, but this does not diminish the general support shown for
the concept. Valid questions were raised during the hearing about the likelihood of people
from Victoria or Mount Stewart, for example, actually driving to the Charlottetown Co-op
to buy gas. This again goes to the market area analysis mentioned earlier.
These were the main evidentiary submissions related to public
convenience, interest and necessity. Overall, the Commission cannot accept that, on
balance, the public convenience, interest and necessity of the motoring public will be
served by granting a license to sell gas as proposed by this Applicant. The evidence of
declining gasoline sales in the core area supports the argument that another licensee will
significantly hurt the remaining operators. The Interveners' testimony about the services
they provide indicate a variety of services to the motoring public that, if lost, would
appear to hurt the motoring public more than they can be helped by the addition of a gas
bar.
The concepts of public convenience, interest and necessity are
difficult to deal with and prove, but it is the overall interest of the motoring public in
the area to be served that is at issue. Co-op members from Mount Stewart interested in a
rebate cannot in our analyses under the Petroleum Products Act take priority over
city motorists who need the package of services being provided by an ever-smaller group of
city outlets.
Counsel for the Applicant suggested that the decline in sales at bay
service outlets suggested that motorists no longer choose to buy at those outlets. To some
extent that position is valid, and for that reason changes in service offerings have been
accepted by the Commission. However, when viewing the convenience, interest and necessity
of the motoring public we look at the overall services available and believe that the
purpose of the licensing provisions is to ensure that we don't over-license an area for no
good reason, i.e. for reasons that do not serve the convenience, interest and necessity of
the motoring public. The investment required to set up an outlet is substantial. While
consumer choice will determine who succeeds in the marketplace generally, we must
interpret the marketplace restrictions in the Petroleum Products Act as giving us
some responsibility for assessing the various service offerings and deciding if there is
justification for adding a new competitor to the mix.
In this case we can't see the justification. The argument about
"needing" a choice to buy Co-op is somewhat diminished by the fact that so many
of the Co-op's customers--and those surveyed--are really non-members. They really would be
competing with the other outlets directly and the possible rebate for members would simply
ensure more sales are likely to be taken from existing operators. In the circumstances,
for the reasons given, we can't see this as being an overall benefit to the motoring
public.
The application is therefore denied in accordance with the appended
Order.
Order
THE COMMISSION HEREBY ORDERS:
THAT the application of Co-Op Atlantic filed on 6 April 1995 for an
initial petroleum products dealer's license with respect to full-serve motor fuels
dispensing in conjunction with an established general merchant outlet located at Oak Tree
Place in Charlottetown and operated by Central Farmers' Co-operative Association, Limited
is denied.